Grades, Course Evaluations, and Academic Incentives
نویسندگان
چکیده
We develop a model that identifies a range of new and somewhat counterintuitive results about how the incentives created by academic institutions affect student and faculty behavior. The model provides a theoretical basis for grade inflation and the behavioral response of students. Comparative statics are used to analyze the effects of institutional expectations placed on faculty. The results show that placing more emphasis on course evaluations exacerbates the problems of grade inflation and can even decrease a professor’s teaching effort. Increased emphasis on research productivity also decreases teaching effort and provides a further incentive to inflate grades. We use the model to analyze how grade targets can control grade inflation and align professorial incentives with institutional objectives. We also discuss the implications of the model for hiring, promotion, and tenure. Eastern Economic Journal (2010) 36, 151 – 163. doi:10.1057/eej.2009.6
منابع مشابه
Academic Policies and Regulations
Academic Honesty Attendance in Class Auditing Courses Credit Hour Classification of Students by Class Level Course Credit Policies Course Registration, Change of Program, and Withdrawal Policies Course Selection Policies Planned Educational Leave Grading System and Policies Definition of Letter Grading Symbols Use of Plus/Minus Symbols Computation of Grade Point Averag...
متن کاملGrades and Incentives: Assessing Competing GPA Measures and Post-Graduate Outcomes
In many educational settings, students may have an incentive to take courses where high grades are easier to achieve, potentially corroding student learning, evaluation of student achievement, and the fairness and efficiency of post-graduation labor outcomes. A grading system that takes into account heterogeneity of teacher standards and student ability could mitigate these problems. Using uniq...
متن کاملRedesign of a large lecture course into a small-group learning course.
Objective. To describe the redesign of a large self-care course previously delivered in a traditional lecture format to a small-group case-based course.Design. Prereadings and study guides were used to facilitate students' independent learning prior to class. Large lecture classes were replaced with smaller group-based learning classes. This change in delivery format allowed students to spend t...
متن کاملCorrecting the bias of clerkship timing on academic performance.
OBJECTIVES To document the time-of-year bias in National Board of Medical Examiners subject examination (NBME) scores in a third-year pediatrics clerkship and to develop a grading method that neutralizes the bias. DESIGN Interventional modeling of final grades. SETTING University-based medical school. SUBJECTS AND METHODS During each of the past 3 academic years, we conducted six 2-month ...
متن کاملCooperative learning and peer evaluation: The effect of free riders on team performance and the relationship between course performance and peer evaluation
Cooperative learning has gained popularity in higher educational settings. However, assigning grades equitably to all team members in a way that rewards them for their contributions remains challenging. In this paper, we ask whether having free riders on a team lowers the quality of submitted work, and whether students’ course performance correlates with peer evaluations. In an introductory soc...
متن کامل